home
***
CD-ROM
|
disk
|
FTP
|
other
***
search
/
hornet.scene.org
/
hornet.scene.org FTP 11-25-2012.zip
/
hornet.scene.org FTP 11-25-2012
/
music
/
contests
/
mc5
/
files
/
mc5-news.003
< prev
next >
Wrap
Text File
|
2012-06-16
|
29KB
|
637 lines
_______ _________ ____ ____
\ \ \_ ___ \ \ \ / /
/ \ / \/ \ \/ \ | /
/ | \ \____ \ /
\____|____/\________/ \___/
Total Entries : 302
Finalist Entries : 45
Music Contest 5 Update 3 - 04 Aug 1997 Total Judges : 184
>------------------------------------------------------------------ Contents --
Introduction
Files
Schedule
Articles
Block Results ................................. GD
Round 1 Results (Finalist Quick-List) ......... Snowman
Round 1 Results (Veteran) ..................... Snowman
Round 1 Results (Intermediate) ................ Snowman
Round 1 Results (Rookie) ...................... Snowman
Closing
>-------------------------------------------------------------- Introduction --
Round 1 voting has come to a close. We would like to thank all of the
participating Music Contest 5 judges. It is now time to announce the
finalist songs.
Be sure to read the "Block Results" article, as it explains the new format
of the Music Contest results.
If you voted in Round 1, you will automatically be emailed your new judging
information for Round 2 in the next day or two. Until then, it would
probably be a good idea to download all entries from the following
directories:
ftp://ftp.hornet.org/pub/demos/music/contests/mc5/rookie/final
ftp://ftp.hornet.org/pub/demos/music/contests/mc5/intermed/final
ftp://ftp.hornet.org/pub/demos/music/contests/mc5/veteran/final
GD / Hornet - gd@hornet.org
Snowman / Hornet - r3cgm@hornet.org
>--------------------------------------------------------------------- Files --
Description Location URL
------------- -------- ------------------------------------------------------
MC5 Web Page USA http://www.hornet.org/music/contests/mc5
MC5 Archive USA ftp://ftp.hornet.org/pub/demos/music/contests/mc5
administrator: r3cgm@hornet.org
-- /music/contests/mc5 ----------------------------------------------------->
/files/mc5-news.001 Music Contest 5 Updates Newsletter issue 1
/files/mc5-news.002 Music Contest 5 Updates Newsletter issue 2
/files/mc5-news.003 Music Contest 5 Updates Newsletter issue 3
>------------------------------------------------------------------ Schedule --
All times are given in GMT (Greenwich Mean Time).
Date Time Event
--------- --------- -------------------------------------------------------
31 May 97 00:00 GMT Contest starts
14 Jul 97 00:00 GMT Entry application deadline
15 Jul 97 00:00 GMT Entry deadline
21 Jul 97 00:00 GMT Voting round 1 begins
03 Aug 97 00:00 GMT Voting round 1 ends
04 Aug 97 00:00 GMT Voting round 2 begins
* <-- YOU ARE HERE
11 Aug 97 00:00 GMT Voting round 2 ends
17 Aug 97 00:00 GMT Contest ends, results released, organizers go home
>------------------------------------------------------------------ Articles --
:: "MC5 Block Results"
:: GD / Hornet - gd@hornet.org
_____Introduction
Only 45 out of 300+ MC5 songs made the final round. Entrants who do not
advance will not get an exact ranking or a score for their song. So how
will they know what their skill level is?
_____Block Results
The "Block Results" concept is our compromise to the two extreme solutions:
no round 1 results are released, or the full round 1 results are released.
Each song that does not make round 2 will not get a score or rank. Instead,
these songs will be grouped into blocks of songs. The song blocks are built
from the "full" results, so they remain in relative order. The song blocks
are then ranked, so entrants will now have at least a general idea of how
their song did.
Songs in each block will be arranged in purely alphabetical order. These
songs will be defined as being relatively close in rank. An average score
will be listed for each block. Average scores are not listed for the
finalist blocks.
_____The Reasoning
Why block results? Why not full results? The MC5 vote tally script easily
provides scores and rankings for every song.
There are three primary reasons for this decision:
1. Entries that do not make the final round technically do not deserve an
exact ranking. Very rarely in large competitions are rankings assigned
to every single entry. There is most often a cutoff number for entries:
a certain number of entries are selected for the final round, and the
rest are simply not ranked.
2. Lower scores are less accurate. When judging a song of high quality,
judges are careful to give a precise evaluation of a song. It is easier
to find a particular quality and take some points off for a minor
deficiency. It is harder to find a particular nuance and assign it a
fair amount of points for "reasonable effort."
When assigning a low score, many judges are simply imprecise because they
know the exact number doesn't have much importance in the overall
results.
Music Contest could use just one round of voting. However, the second
voting round is used to provide extreme accuracy for the final results.
Each song in Round 1 will get about 5 to 7 votes. In Round 2, each song
gets over 50 votes (if the voting operates as expected).
3. Exact rankings and scores for those at the bottom of the scale can result
in ridicule. We have a responsibility to the scene to not cause anyone
undeserved grief. Ripping an entry deserves public ridicule, but
overestimating one's skill level is simply a matter of inexperience.
_____The Compromise
Why was this concept added to MC5?
Full results and scores were given for all entries in MC3. In MC4, with the
addition of the two-round voting process, only the round 2 finalists were
given a rank and score. We received a significant amount of feedback from
individuals who disliked the partial MC4 results policy.
With only partial results, competing individuals who do not make the final
round have little way of knowing how they did. One of the fundamental
concepts of the Music Contest is to give everyone a chance to compete with
each other. People deserve to see how well they do against composers they
might not otherwise compete against.
_____Conclusion
This new method of providing Music Contest results benefits everyone. The
round 2 finalists still get an exact score and ranking. Non-finalists get
a relative ranking. Everyone will know, to some degree, how well their song
performed.
=-----------------------------------------------------------------------------=
:: "Round 1 Results (Finalist Quick-List)"
:: Snowman / Hornet - r3cgm@hornet.org
These entries are sorted in alphabetical order, and do not reflect how the
songs did _relative_ to each other.
Top 20 Veteran Top 15 Intermediate Top 10 Rookie
----------------------- ----------------------- -----------------------
m5v-aber m5i-asin m5r-abax
m5v-alon m5i-bagh m5r-bts
m5v-digi m5i-dbtc m5r-dtn
m5v-elfs m5i-fft m5r-frel
m5v-emel m5i-hbl m5r-hafa
m5v-fant m5i-iir m5r-lunx
m5v-fiel m5i-lgdm m5r-sbf
m5v-flow m5i-medi m5r-trbp
m5v-gldn m5i-orxn m5r-ttn
m5v-letl m5i-rmbr m5r-wave
m5v-mars m5i-snst
m5v-nine m5i-stor
m5v-prev m5i-tes
m5v-siir m5i-tews
m5v-slik m5i-tunt
m5v-sotw
m5v-sway
m5v-time
m5v-twi
m5v-wond
=-----------------------------------------------------------------------------=
:: "Round 1 Results (Veteran)"
:: Snowman / Hornet - r3cgm@hornet.org
The top 20 veteran songs qualify for Round 2.
The entries in each block are sorted in alphabetical order, and do not
reflect how they did _relative_ to each other.
Title Title Country
--------- ----------------------------------- -------------------------------
m5v-aber Aberration Canada
m5v-alon Alone Australia
m5v-digi Digital Ritual Usa
m5v-elfs The Elfs' Village Italy
m5v-emel Emelie Sweden
m5v-fant Fantasy Usa
m5v-fiel Yellow Fields Norway
m5v-flow Flow Moon Finland
m5v-gldn Goldenrod Usa
m5v-letl Let It Loose Sweden
m5v-mars Martian Lovesong Usa
m5v-nine Nine One One Netherlands
m5v-prev Protonic Reversal Usa
m5v-siir Symphony In Infrared Usa
m5v-slik Slickshift Usa
m5v-sotw Song Of The Winds Finland
m5v-sway Stairway Australia
m5v-time Time Flows Canada
m5v-twi Twilight Groove Usa
m5v-wond Words Of No Difference Sweden
^^^---------- Songs above this line have qualified for round 2! ----------^^^
m5v-atec Above The Eagles' Cries Usa
m5v-dsky A Different Sky Uk
m5v-duet Duet Usa
m5v-flud Flood Uk
m5v-lovs Love In The Stars Germany
m5v-pair Matching Pair Denmark, Sweden
m5v-salv Second Salvation Usa
m5v-secl Secluded Lagoon Netherlands
m5v-tide Tides Italy
m5v-tlus Tantalus Usa
^^^--------------- Average Score (songs 021 - 030) : 72.17 ---------------^^^
m5v-fos Flight To The Other Side Australia
m5v-frid Friday Night Usa
m5v-gwop Gardens Without Peace... Portugal
m5v-habl Hats And Barrels Uk
m5v-hol Holoscope Australia
m5v-litc Lost In The Cold Usa
m5v-litt Little Mascerade Norway
m5v-silk Silk Touch France
m5v-star Starrider I. Slovakia
m5v-sylp Sylphide Wings Usa
^^^--------------- Average Score (songs 031 - 040) : 70.18 ---------------^^^
m5v-alch The Alchemist Finland
m5v-antc Antechamber Usa
m5v-coqu Coquillage Usa
m5v-dest Clandestine Destiny Usa
m5v-holy Holy Writ Brazil
m5v-jsaf Jazz Safari Australia
m5v-phot Photosynthesis Canada
m5v-puri Purification Usa
m5v-trfr True Friend Italy
m5v-wol Whisper Of Love Australia
^^^--------------- Average Score (songs 041 - 050) : 68.29 ---------------^^^
m5v-bisw Bitter Sweetness Netherlands
m5v-hghr Higher And Higher Usa
m5v-hllc Hallucinogenic Usa
m5v-lost Lost Paradise Iceland
m5v-nwlf My New Life Italy
m5v-sgaz Stargazer Uk
m5v-shad The Shadow Exploded Luxembourg
m5v-unq Unanswered Questions Usa
m5v-witp Walking In The Park Sweden
m5v-zeni Zenith Of Time Usa
^^^--------------- Average Score (songs 051 - 060) : 64.94 ---------------^^^
m5v-clus The Clusterkind Usa
m5v-cold cold.hearted.bitch Usa
m5v-cym Change Your Mind France
m5v-dark Dark Structures Usa
m5v-dbrk Day Break Usa
m5v-heat Icy Heat Brazil
m5v-mna Mana4 Australia
m5v-pesh Pesh Dimensions Norway
m5v-tal Tracks And Lines Uk
m5v-wtf Wear Tito's Funk Usa
^^^--------------- Average Score (songs 061 - 070) : 60.39 ---------------^^^
m5v-fire Yell Fire Canada
m5v-glut Sinnenglut Germany
m5v-han Hard As Nails Italy
m5v-hang Hanging Time Israel
m5v-hbit Habits Netherlands
m5v-past Running Past Usa
m5v-sill Silhouettes Canada
m5v-sipt Superimposed Thoughts Canada
m5v-worl Other Worlds Netherlands
m5v-zila Godzilla Usa
^^^--------------- Average Score (songs 071 - 080) : 55.58 ---------------^^^
m5v-anna Anna Usa
m5v-blss Bliss Germany
m5v-dopa Dopadelika Italy
m5v-gbjo Get Back Jojo Russia
m5v-mrmd Mr. Madman Slovakia
m5v-need Need To Suffer Italy
m5v-sql Squelch Usa
m5v-tgtw The Green Twist Finland
m5v-visi Visions Australia
m5v-what Oh, No! Help Me! I Can't Take It! W Usa
^^^--------------- Average Score (songs 081 - 090) : 49.99 ---------------^^^
m5v-aptc Apprentice Usa
m5v-care Carexidentifyerworx Germany
m5v-moth Moments Of Truth Iceland
m5v-mwtf The Magic World In 35mm Brazil
m5v-narf The Question (what Is Narf?) Usa
m5v-ontf On To The Future Australia
m5v-pars Parsoniana Italy
m5v-som Sins Of Masochism Usa
m5v-tbdr The Broken Drumloop Germany
m5v-wood Waltz Woods Norway
^^^--------------- Average Score (songs 091 - 100) : 44.28 ---------------^^^
=-----------------------------------------------------------------------------=
:: "Round 1 Results (Intermediate)"
:: Snowman / Hornet - r3cgm@hornet.org
The top 15 intermediate songs qualify for Round 2.
The entries in each block are sorted in alphabetical order, and do not
reflect how they did _relative_ to each other.
Title Title Country
--------- ----------------------------------- -------------------------------
m5i-asin As In A Dream Usa
m5i-bagh The Streets Of Baghdad Usa
m5i-dbtc Day Before The Cataclysm Australia
m5i-fft Five Time Usa
m5i-hbl Hot Borrito Lambada Australia
m5i-iir It's Raining Poland
m5i-lgdm Legerdemain Usa
m5i-medi Medievel Journey Israel
m5i-orxn Orientxpression Bulgaria
m5i-rmbr Remembrance Czech Republic
m5i-snst Sunset Usa
m5i-stor The Storyteller Israel
m5i-tes The Elephant Stomp Sweden
m5i-tews The East Wing Study Finland
m5i-tunt The Tunturi Finland
^^^---------- Songs above this line have qualified for round 2! ----------^^^
m5i-bell Bellona Norway
m5i-imag Imaginary Usa
m5i-ivan Ivan Czech Republic
m5i-mpf My Purple Frisbee Usa
m5i-tame Tame Usa
^^^--------------- Average Score (songs 016 - 020) : 65.57 ---------------^^^
m5i-daem Daemon Girl Uk
m5i-drea Dream Wave Sweden
m5i-hvns Heavens Usa
m5i-imov Immortal Move Germany
m5i-mdrm Midnight Dream Slovakia
m5i-mnlb Midnight Lullaby Usa
m5i-ptdt Pocket Development Sweden
m5i-re Reliving Spain
m5i-rotp Return Of The Prince Usa
m5i-swee Sweetly Beguiled Finland
^^^--------------- Average Score (songs 021 - 030) : 62.85 ---------------^^^
m5i-broc Sunday Morning Brocolli Canada
m5i-bwl Blind World Living Russia
m5i-nwhr Nowhere Finland
m5i-pola Polar Seas Usa
m5i-ssno But She Said No Spain
m5i-subr Summer Breeze Sweden
m5i-thsr The Suplana Revival Russia
m5i-tmqr The Missing Quarter Israel
m5i-trns Trans Hungary
m5i-wind Windward Usa
^^^--------------- Average Score (songs 031 - 040) : 60.05 ---------------^^^
m5i-fdiy Feel The Devil In Yourself Russia
m5i-lotw Light Of The World Usa
m5i-midn Midnight Ensemble Canada
m5i-mshp Meshing People Usa
m5i-qos The Queen Of Snow Spain
m5i-smjt Project Jt Germany
m5i-trod Three Toed Tree Trod Usa
m5i-turb Turbulence Estonia
m5i-ywr Yakuma Warrior Holland
m5i-zoom Zoom Usa
^^^--------------- Average Score (songs 041 - 050) : 58.14 ---------------^^^
m5i-farm Farm Animals Canada
m5i-mank Mankind Canada
m5i-mhai My Hat And I Canada
m5i-mtds Methods Sweden
m5i-puzz Puzzle Poland
m5i-sor Sorrow Belgium
m5i-sotm Secrets Of The Mind - Dream Sweden
m5i-soul Soul's Remorse Australia
m5i-toso Two Souls Russia
m5i-viru Virulent Criterion Usa
^^^--------------- Average Score (songs 051 - 060) : 55.22 ---------------^^^
m5i-bhor Beautiful Horror Netherlands
m5i-brai Brainstorm Norway
m5i-cont Contradictions Usa
m5i-desc Descent Australia
m5i-eos Erosion Of Society Usa
m5i-jack Remembering Jack Usa
m5i-lum Luminescence Usa
m5i-mda Mda Usa
m5i-tpst Times Past Usa
m5i-ttcc Lake Titicaca Finland
^^^--------------- Average Score (songs 061 - 070) : 52.47 ---------------^^^
m5i-crse The Curse Canada
m5i-fegn Feign Innocence Usa
m5i-jrny The Journey Ahead Usa
m5i-lmmb Leaving My Mind Behind Usa
m5i-peac Peacemaker Sweden
m5i-pssi Sly Spy Usa
m5i-scpi Stan Colella: Private Eye Usa
m5i-sham Shameful Usa
m5i-tmar The March Norway
m5i-tpp The Prostitute Principle Canada
^^^--------------- Average Score (songs 071 - 080) : 49.06 ---------------^^^
m5i-abd Abercorn Ditty Usa
m5i-angr Anger Usa
m5i-char Charismatic Usa
m5i-chln Chemical Land Usa
m5i-inme Internal Mechanism Iceland
m5i-jbob Jizrobob Usa
m5i-neb Nebulous Usa
m5i-ptis In Space Usa
m5i-pudb Pick Up Da Bassline Uk
m5i-ragi Ragibo's Revenge Usa
m5i-rjs Reject Society Usa
m5i-seiz Seizure Of Time Usa
m5i-taba There And Back Again (bilbo) Germany
m5i-tati TΣhtisumu Canada
m5i-tiyt This Is Your Towelette Usa
m5i-visn Vision Usa
m5i-wns Wild Nights Usa
^^^--------------- Average Score (songs 081 - 097) : 35.58 ---------------^^^
=-----------------------------------------------------------------------------=
:: "Round 1 Results (Rookie)"
:: Snowman / Hornet - r3cgm@hornet.org
The top 10 rookie songs qualify for Round 2.
The entries in each block are sorted in alphabetical order, and do not
reflect how they did _relative_ to each other.
Title Title Country
--------- ----------------------------------- -------------------------------
m5r-abax Abaxis Uk
m5r-bts Below The Surface Usa
m5r-dtn Distance To Neera Sweden
m5r-frel Funky Religion Sweden
m5r-hafa Hafasika Usa
m5r-lunx Lunar Excursion Usa
m5r-sbf Shaped By Fear Canada
m5r-trbp Travelling By Piano Poland
m5r-ttn True To Nature Usa
m5r-wave WAVE New Zealand
^^^---------- Songs above this line have qualified for round 2! ----------^^^
m5r-cotf Children Of The Indigo Flowers Canada
m5r-dims Dream In My Soul Italy
m5r-espe Entering Space On Purple Eyes Russia
m5r-happ Happiness Forever Canada
m5r-mshe Musicbox She Finland
m5r-play Modern Playboy Sweden
m5r-rts Reaching The Sky Usa
m5r-scle Sacred Lifeline Uk
m5r-ttbo The Two Become One Usa
m5r-vsns Visions Czech Republic
^^^--------------- Average Score (songs 011 - 020) : 58.55 ---------------^^^
m5r-afrl Army From Rlyeh France
m5r-bkpr Broken Paradise Uk
m5r-dbch The Debate Changes Usa
m5r-dofd Dreams Of Deception Usa
m5r-escl Escaping Life Usa
m5r-ilsn Illusionary World Bulgaria
m5r-lywm Loosing You... Israel
m5r-pitz Pitzdahero Germany
m5r-stfo Six Trillion Feet Over Usa
m5r-unfd Unfulfilled Desires Usa
^^^--------------- Average Score (songs 021 - 030) : 55.62 ---------------^^^
m5r-amok Amok Greece
m5r-cdyn Crystal Dynasty Usa
m5r-dnf Downfall Russia
m5r-nwbr New Breed Of Old Usa
m5r-octf October Fog Usa
m5r-pty Purgatory Usa
m5r-tkex The Khalil Experience Spain
m5r-tqmm Tranquil Memory Usa
m5r-vom Vomit Sweden
m5r-waig Water Is Good Denmark
^^^--------------- Average Score (songs 031 - 040) : 51.91 ---------------^^^
m5r-blow Blow Up The World! Dominican Republic
m5r-dots Dance Of The Shadows Canada
m5r-dtra Dream-train Finland
m5r-fnbs First Night By The Sea Russia
m5r-mgam Mindgames Russia
m5r-pulz Pulse Sweden
m5r-trdm Trance Dreams Australia
m5r-ttwn Then There Were None Usa
m5r-uatd Unable To Dream Usa
m5r-wsdw We Smoken Da Weed Canada
^^^--------------- Average Score (songs 041 - 050) : 49.15 ---------------^^^
m5r-cap Cats At Play Uk
m5r-cgrv Corpulent Groove Usa
m5r-ctcl Cataclism Slovenia
m5r-dawn Tomorrow's Dawn Usa
m5r-fade Fade Canada
m5r-jst Sour Thoughts 97 Czech Republic
m5r-pand Pandora Usa
m5r-rawn Rawn Norway
m5r-sirn Siren's Reflection Usa
m5r-yest To Yesterday... Usa
^^^--------------- Average Score (songs 051 - 060) : 45.61 ---------------^^^
m5r-ami I Am Not Ami Sweden
m5r-ftz Fanatazy Usa
m5r-hom Hard On Me Israel
m5r-mirr Mirror Universe Usa
m5r-piwa Piercing Water Usa
m5r-surg Surge Usa
m5r-tech Tech-o-matic Australia
m5r-tral Jungle Trail Usa
m5r-tytf The Youth, The Future Usa
m5r-wake Wake Of Sorrow Usa
^^^--------------- Average Score (songs 061 - 070) : 42.57 ---------------^^^
m5r-anpd Another Production Denmark
m5r-crpr Circle Prime Usa
m5r-elys Electric Ladyshave Finland
m5r-esi Earth Sought Imni India
m5r-nova Supernova Usa
m5r-ste Ett Trevligh Litet Hus Sweden
m5r-tamu Tamuli Usa
m5r-tce The Cassandra Effect Usa
m5r-thir Thirteen Usa
m5r-udrm Utopian Dreams Canada
^^^--------------- Average Score (songs 071 - 080) : 39.37 ---------------^^^
m5r-clmm Clouded Memory Usa
m5r-ftof Feel The Heat Of The Fire Israel
m5r-klrr Killer R Usa
m5r-mess Messiah Canada
m5r-ocmy Oceanic Mystique Usa
m5r-odsy Spiritual Oddysey Usa
m5r-prl Promised Land Brazil
m5r-rowa Ride On Waves Slovakia
m5r-sub Sound Of Urban Bruise France
m5r-susd Sustained Desperation Canada
^^^--------------- Average Score (songs 081 - 090) : 36.16 ---------------^^^
m5r-beim Beatime Canada
m5r-bush Lost In A Bush Canada
m5r-chia Chiakloq Sweden
m5r-chip Chippy Fun Usa
m5r-etn E. T. 9000 Usa
m5r-from Forests Of Magic Canada
m5r-kneo Know Eachother Usa
m5r-llgb Loa & Legba Usa
m5r-loma Life On Mars Usa
m5r-lust Lust Maker Australia
m5r-msbx Music Box Usa
m5r-nowr Nowhere In Spave Usa
m5r-pac Pacadatphia Usa
m5r-prim M5r-prim.xm Thailand
m5r-rock Rocktherythymthat'llmakeyourbodydro Usa
^^^--------------- Average Score (songs 091 - 105) : 25.14 ---------------^^^
>------------------------------------------------------------------- Closing --
_____Contact Information
Send general questions and comments to GD (Brett Neely), gd@hornet.org
Questions and comments regarding the webpages, online registration, or entry
verification should be sent to Snowman (Christopher G. Mann),
r3cgm@hornet.org
The MC5 homepage is at http://www.hornet.org/music/contests/mc5
_____How to Subscribe to "MC5 Updates"
Mail to : listserver@unseen.aztec.co.za
Body : subscribe mc5-updates first_name last_name
Be sure to substitute your real name for first_name last_name. The
listserver will send the MC5 Newsletter to your e-mail's return address.
EOMC5UPD